The Times West Virginian

WVU Sports

September 6, 2012

HERTZEL COLUMN: Experience should fix early miscues

MORGANTOWN — You will get no argument if you were to believe that West Virginia University’s Dana Holgorsen is one of the brightest shining lights in the football coaching profession, possessing a great offensive mind, a knack for organizing and getting through to his players and now carrying an Orange Bowl trophy and book full of records on his resume.

But he is a young coach, just in his second season as a head coach, and as such there are some rough edges that come along with being young and inexperienced.

He does not hold the market on it. Geno Smith, for example, was a better quarterback his third season than during his second and is expected to be better in this, his fourth.

It’s no different with coaches than it is with players, for the greatest teacher is experience, and the mistakes you make or the misguided approach you have today will lead to corrections as you go along. Some coaches can do this without suffering from it in the terms of losses, but it happens to all of them and Holgorsen openly expressed a couple of his following the opening victory over Marshall.

True, from the outside, it was difficult to find fault with a 69-34 victory, but there were a couple of problems exposed that experience will probably correct.

The first occurred when the game was still undecided — which means early. It was the end of the first quarter, WVU holding a 13-0 advantage but now at the end of a nifty drive that had taken the ball to the Marshall 1 on third down.

Prior to the game, Holgorsen had told his team that he was looking for physical football, and he was hell bent on getting it, mixing in enough runs that featured Shawne Alston and Andrew Buie inside that Marshall didn’t quite know what to do.

Well, on this third-down play from the 1, he gave the ball to his 236-pound running back Alston and he was stuffed, losing two yards.

Everyone expected the field goal unit, which would have given WVU a three-possession lead, or if Holgorsen felt like gambling a rollout pass or fade to Stedman Bailey.

Imagine the surprise when they came out in a conventional under-center formation and Smith tried to sneak the ball three yards into the end zone.

“Terrible call,” Holgorsen would say later in his press conference.

That’s allowed. Coaches make bad calls all the time. The problem wasn’t really with the call, but the reason behind it, which showed inexperience and youth.

“That was me being stupid and stubborn,” Holgorsen continued. “It was (third-and-goal) and we tempoed them because they subbed and we caught them and we tried to punch it in (on the Alston play), which is what we’re always going to do. We lost a yard and I got mad and became stubborn and took three points away from the team, which was not very smart.”

Certainly, Smith was stunned when he looked over at the sideline and saw the call.

“Oh, man, that was tough,” the quarterback said. “Coach told me it was a bad call, and he probably should have kicked. I like that he trusted us, and he trusted in me and put the ball in my hands.”

The troublesome part of all this, of course, isn’t the call and it isn’t the result.

Instead, it is that he let his emotions overwhelm his thinking. He was stubborn and mad, and a coach can’t allow himself to let either influence his coaching decisions.

To this day no one can say that Pitt didn’t beat WVU when it was on the doorstep of the national championship game in 2007 because then-coach Rich Rodriguez wasn’t being stubborn and going to beat the 24-point underdog Panthers by running the ball rather than taking advantage of a huge opening deep down the middle for passes.

Rodriguez was, like Holgorsen, an offensive genius, but he absolutely refused to adjust that day and play to the circumstances, just as Holgorsen wanted to prove a point rather than score one in this situation.

And speaking of points, Marshall made 34 of them in the game, along with 545 yards, 413 of them through the air.

Following the game, Holgorsen’s statement to the media was somewhat startling, coming from a coach’s mouth.

“As far as how many yards we gave up is something we’re not going to be too concerned with at this point,” he said.

The statement was in keeping with the idea the coaching staff had expressed that the defense was new, the players not experienced in it and that the goal was to cause turnovers rather than stop the opponent.

“At the end of the game, as long as we have more points than they do — then we’ve done our job,” defensive coordinator Joe DeForest said during camp. “We may win ugly at times, but ultimately if you come out on top that means you made a stop to win the game.”

While true, it is hardly a way to drive a defensive team toward playing at the top of its game, and it’s the kind of statement that you probably won’t hear out of a coach with experience who wants his defense to play at its best always.

Email Bob Hertzel at bhertzel@hotmail.com or follow him on Twitter @bhertzel.

Text Only
WVU Sports
  • HERTZEL COLUMN- Major delivers message: ‘Roll with the punches’

    On graduation day, four or five or who knows how many years into one’s college days, you expect to put on your cap and gown and listen to words of wisdom from a commencement speaker more along the lines of Henry Kissinger or Bill Clinton, but that is not to say it is only a day for an academic elitist.

    May 20, 2013

  • WVU wins regular-season finale

    The West Virginia University baseball team guaranteed itself a Top 4 finish in the Big 12 Conference standings with a 5-4 victory at No. 16 Oklahoma State on Saturday afternoon at Allie P. Reynolds Stadium.

    May 19, 2013

  • HERTZEL COLUMN: Irvin’s dreads are gone now he must rebuild reputation

    A couple of days back Bruce Irvin sat down in a barber’s chair — stylist’s chair, if you prefer — and made a dramatic and what had to be traumatic move.
    He had his dreadlocks removed.

    May 19, 2013

  • FURFARI COLUMN: Harrick greatest WVU two-sport coach

    The late Steve Harrick was the longest-serving, most-successful two-sport head coach in West Virginia University’s athletic history.

    May 19, 2013

  • HERTZEL COLUMN: Flying WV logo draws attention outside country

    Sometimes you hit a nerve, as we did a while back when we wrote about the wide reach of West Virginia University’s flying WV logo.
    It has meant a lot to a lot of people.

    May 18, 2013

  • Seahawks’ Bruce Irvin suspended four games

    Bruce Irvin, one of only two West Virginia University defensive linemen ever to be selected in the first round of the NFL draft, will miss the first four games of the 2014 National Football League season because of a failed test for performance-enhancing drugs.

    May 18, 2013

  • WVU falls to Oklahoma State, 5-0

    The West Virginia University baseball dropped its fifth consecutive game with a 5-0 loss to No. 16 Oklahoma State on Friday evening at Allie P. Reynolds Stadium.

    May 18, 2013

  • Reaves rejoins Carey as an assistant coach

    Mike Carey has run through a lot of assistant basketball coaches during his time at West Virginia University, so it comes as no surprise that he has started repeating assistants.
    Carey announced on Friday that Sharrona Reaves has returned as an assistant on his West Virginia staff.

    May 18, 2013

  • HERTZEL COLUMN: Opportunity to see birth of greatness

    Sometimes things happen and the significance of them isn’t fully grasped immediately. So it is with the approval of the TIFF financing for a baseball stadium just off I-79 here in Morgantown.
    Obviously, this a boon for the West Virginia University baseball program of Randy Mazey, which gains instant creditability.

    May 17, 2013

  • Musgrave ranks among top pitchers in college baseball

    West Virginia University’s redshirt sophomore left-hander Harrison Musgrave’s spectacular season has reached the pinnacle of the heights a collegiate pitcher can attain as he has been named a finalist for the College Baseball Hall of Fame Pitcher of the Year Award.

    May 17, 2013

Featured Ads
WVU Sports Highlights
NDN Sports
House Ads