The Times West Virginian

WVU Sports

September 6, 2010

HERTZEL COLUMN - WVU gears up for date with Herd

MORGANTOWN — The paint had barely dried on West Virginia’s opening 31-0 victory over an outclassed Coastal Carolina team when the order went out to nearest Sherwin Williams store for as much green paint as it could send over to Puskar Stadium.

This is Marshall week and with the game in Huntington, might as well get this stirred up group of Mountaineers prepared to see some green.

As rivalries go, this Friends of Coal Bowl is something of a weak one. There have been no upsets in it ever, stretching all the way back to 1911 when Marshall got as close as it would come to beating WVU, falling 17-15.

By 1915 West Virginia had grown to the point that it would rout Marshall, 92-0, putting the series on hold until 1923, not that much had changed in those eight years, considering that WVU won that game, 81-0.

That WVU is 9-0 in the series tells you that it has been terribly one-sided, the Mountaineers even able to win when the series was renewed — sort of — in 1997 when Marshall had both Randy Moss, a sure NFL Hall of Fame receiver, and quarterback Chad Pennington, who still is flinging in the NFL.

But there has been a series that has had its share of chicanery, too, beginning back in that 92-6 game.

Amazingly, this is an important game in Marshall lore, for if they didn’t beat WVU, they outwitted them.

Marshall came into the game 0-5 and had been outscored 127-6. Mountaineer Coach Sol Metzger was so sure that his team would shut out Marshall that he vowed he’d “eat my hat if Marshall scores.”

On cue, WVU jumped to a three-touchdown lead but Marshall recovered a fumble and hit a few passes to move the ball to the Mountaineer 15. Marshall brought an athletic back named Dayton Carter into the game.

The Herd quarterback Brad Workman, faded to pass under great pressure, but somehow Marshall tackle “Blondie” Taylor and Carter streaked into the end zone. Nicknamed “Runt”, Carter was hoisted onto the back tackle’s shoulders and Workman threw a high pass in their direction.

Carter, now at least a head and a half higher than any WVU defender as he stood on the shoulders, grabbed the ball and fell into the end zone for a score.

Metzger exploded in anger, argued long and hard but there was no rule in place to outlaw the play, which came to be known as “The Tower Play.”

If this did get Marshall on the board, it served only to elevate Metzger’s blood pressure and he did not let up until it was 92-6.

The fates were not kind to Marshall over the years, the tragic plane wreck that killed 75 people annihilating the program to the point that it had to be completely rebuilt.

WVU, meanwhile, had grown into the bully on the block that was West Virginia and saw no reason to play Marshall but agreed to renew the series in 1997, only to have Marshall back out of the agreement after that one game with Randy Moss and Pennington.

It gook Gov. Joe Manchin until 2006 to cajole both sides into another agreement, one which

now is kind of in limbo. It ends in three years unless and new deal can be worked out.

“Right now there’s three more games left and I’m sure it will be discussed by people above me,” said WVU Coach Bill Stewart when asked if he thought the “The Friends of Coal Bowl” series should continue or was a divisive factor within the state. “We will fulfill what the contract calls for but it will be handled by other people before it’s passed down the line to me.”

What Stewart has to do is ready his team for probably the most intriguing matchup since bad blood was spilled when Marshall caught what appeared to be a scout for Coach Rich Rodriguez, driving his wife’s car, at one of its practices.

The setting in this game matches Stewart against Doc Holliday, who was his assistant for a couple of years and who was long a Don Nehlen assistant. Holliday tried to get the job when Rodriguez left but Stewart was selected over him.

A year ago he bolted to Marshall, and already there seems to be some bad blood flowing as there were whispers that Marshall had planned to turn WVU for a minor violation they self reported this spring, then would up having a Mountaineer recruit who had enrolled but had not been cleared academically transfer to Marshall.

Holliday, of course, would have more knowledge of Stewart’s system than anyone else, considering his background, but he scoffs at the idea that it will matter.

“If I have to make any plays Friday night we’re probably in trouble,” Holliday told the Charleston Gazette.

And Stewart indicated he didn’t have to change much because Holliday would be on the other sideline.

“We change our signs every year,” he said, “and we huddle now and use wrist bands. I see it as a waste of time to try for someone else to steal signals. All I want to do is play ball.”

In the end, that’s what it is going to come down to, playing between the lines in a Friday night game that doesn’t figure to be as competitive as some of the high school games across the state it will be detracting from.

E-mail Bob Hertzel at bhertzel@hotmail.com.

Text Only
WVU Sports
  • Streaking Louisville visits WVU

    Everyone has focused on West Virginia University’s rivalry with Pittsburgh as a potential victim of the move to the Big 12 by the Mountaineers, but there is another rivalry that almost certainly will be coming to an end, and while the feelings are not as bitter, the games often are as hard-fought and tense.

    February 11, 2012

  • Verbal agreement: $20 million to Big East

    West Virginia University and the Big East have reached a verbal agreement that will allow the Mountaineers to join the Big 12 on July 1 and play all sports in that conference this year, according to a source and published reports.
    A total of $20 million will go to the Big East to allow WVU to skip the 27-month waiting period stipulated in conference bylaws and to cover the damages caused by possibly playing with just seven members this season.

    February 11, 2012

  • HERTZEL COLUMN: Mountaineers of past won’t forget Brawl

    It is difficult to write about a story that is just beginning but that will never end, that being, of course, West Virginia University’s move to the Big 12 from the Big East, a move that may well signal the end of the Backyard Brawl.

    February 11, 2012

  • Holmes to play in McDonald’s All American games

    Bria Holmes, a signee to the class of 2012-13 West Virginia University women’s basketball team, has been selected to play in the 11th annual McDonald’s All American Girls Game.
    Holmes becomes the first-ever female player out of the state of Connecticut to be selected to the roster.

    February 11, 2012

  • WVU, Big East reach agreement

    West Virginia University and the Big East have reached a conditional agreement that will allow the Mountaineers to join the Big 12 on July 1 and play football there next season, the Charleston Daily Mail reported Thursday night, citing an unidentified source.

    February 10, 2012

  • HERTZEL COLUMN: This WVU team different from previous squads

    Games may be won or lost under glaring lights of a college arena, filled with faithful fans and the prying eye of the ever-present, unblinking television camera, but teams are built in a far different way.
    They come together in a gym that smells of sweat and yesterday’s hotdogs.

    February 10, 2012

  • Notre Dame stops WVU, 55-51

    If Kevin Jones could have scored 20 points against Notre Dame on Wednesday night before a disappointing crowd of 9,258 in the Coliseum he would have joined Jerry West and Hot Rod Hundley in the West Virginia record books.

    February 9, 2012

  • HERTZEL COLUMN: It’s unfair to consider Truck villain

    The zero next to Truck Bryant’s name stood out like an obscene gesture during a Super Bowl halftime show.
    Some even said he was M.I.A. as West Virginia University lost a heartbreaker, if not a season-breaker, to Notre Dame, 55-51.

    February 9, 2012

  • Jones nears milestone as Notre Dame visits WVU

    That it is a crucial game in a season that seems to have nothing but, today’s 9 p.m. visit to the Coliseum by a streaking Notre Dame team comes with a historical footnote in the history of West Virginia University basketball.
    Kevin Jones enters the game having scored 20 or more points in nine consecutive games.

    February 8, 2012

  • WVU source: Battle to join Big 12 nearing conclusion

    Indications were growing that West Virginia University’s battle to leave the Big East and join the Big 12 in time for the 2012 season was about to be won, possibly as early as today.
    A source within the Mountaineer athletic department said on Tuesday that the matter was nearing a conclusion and also told the Times West Virginian that West Virginia would be reinstating a golf team to compete in the Big 12.

    February 8, 2012