The Times West Virginian

WVU Sports

April 11, 2010

HERTZEL COLUMN: Now is hardly the end for WVU’s Butler

MORGANTOWN — The tendency is always to forget that behind that storm cloud that hangs so menacingly in the sky sits the bright, warm sun and that, in the end, we will all be bathed in its warmth.

This is especially true when you see a gifted athlete like Da’Sean Butler crumble onto the court under his own basket, his team far behind in the biggest game he has ever played, his face contorted in pain, his body wiggling on the floor like a flounder than has just been pulled into the boat.

At that moment, as his coach, Bob Huggins, leaves his bench and comes out onto the floor, fully aware this is something more than just a cramp or a sprain, an arena filled with more than 70,000 fans is filled with the fog of grief and the sound of silence.

Da’Sean Butler’s pain suddenly becomes all our pain, those wearing the blue of Duke and all the entire Mountaineer nation that has lived through four years of thrills provided by Butler, who suddenly seems so vulnerable after never having missed a game.

It is the nature of the beast to think of the worst, to forget we live in an age of miracles. If Butler were proved human and vulnerable at that moment, if his spot in the National Basketball Association draft was suddenly eradicated, it does not mean his spot in the National Basketball Association goes with it.

When the news came out Thursday that Butler had undergone reconstructive surgery on the tattered ACL in his left knee and that such surgery was performed at The Andrews Institute in Gulf Breeze, Fla., the first ray of sunshine began peering from behind that ominous cloud.

This is the Mecca of orthopedic surgery, Dr. James Andrews’ gift to the world of athletics.

It is where broken bodies go to heal.

We’re not talking about your beer league softball player, although he, too, is welcome.

We’re talking about the likes of Tom Brady and Brett Favre, a pair of quarterbacks you may know, who have spent much time having the gifted Dr. Andrews’ work with them on their injuries. After his throwing arm was nearly torn from his shoulder, a quarterback named Drew Brees went to have Dr. Andrews perform his miracle.

Whether Dr. Andrews or one of his protégés operated, Da’Sean Butler can rest assured this wasn’t a case of the all the king’s men putting Humpty Dumpty back together again. This was the chicken who would lay the egg anew.

Roger Clemens had his shoulder repaired by Andrews in 1985 and won 95 percent of his games after that. John Smoltz went in for shoulder surgery and two years later saved 55 games. Thousands have had Tommy John surgery performed by Dr. Andrews, who can claim more pitching victories than the 10 greatest winners of all time put together.

If he could fix the ACLs of Jerry Rice and Carson Palmer, he and his people can give Butler all of the best chance to recover that he can get.

Once upon a time such an injury was a death sentence for a basketball career or a football career.

Today, though, they do these things the way they used to remove tonsils. In you go, they build you a new ACL, stitch you back up and they get you into rehabilitation almost before you come out of the anesthesia.

The hope for athletes being put together again began in Los Angeles with Dr. Frank Jobe, who in 1974 took a tendon from a different part of the body and used it to replace a torn ulnar collateral ligament in the elbow, saving an untold number of careers as he invented Tommy John surgery.

The surgery was so successful that it led Cincinnati’s Pete Rose to comment after facing John:

“I know they had to graft a new arm on Tommy John, but did it have to be Sandy Koufax’s?”

To this day John marvels about one thing that came out of his revolutionary surgery.

“You know what I’m most proud of? What I’m most proud of, and I don’t know if anybody from surgery can say this, but I pitched 13 years after the procedure and I never missed a start. Not one iota of trouble. I’d like people to remember that about me,” he said.

The point is that it is not over for Da’Sean Butler, that there is a career out there waiting for him to play out from start to finish, performing on as high or on a higher level than he did this past year.

“In my experience, high-level athletes often come back from injury better athletes than before their procedure. The reason, I believe, is that these athletes focus their rehab on areas of strength that have often been neglected. By focusing on rehab, elite athletes can gain a competitive advantage,” orthopedic surgeon Dr. Jonathan Cluett wrote recently.

And so it is that the sun will come out soon for Da’Sean Butler, perhaps brighter and warmer than ever.

E-mail Bob Hertzel at bhertzel@hotmail.com.

Text Only
WVU Sports
  • Jones nears milestone as Notre Dame visits WVU

    That it is a crucial game in a season that seems to have nothing but, today’s 9 p.m. visit to the Coliseum by a streaking Notre Dame team comes with a historical footnote in the history of West Virginia University basketball.
    Kevin Jones enters the game having scored 20 or more points in nine consecutive games.

    February 8, 2012

  • WVU source: Battle to join Big 12 nearing conclusion

    Indications were growing that West Virginia University’s battle to leave the Big East and join the Big 12 in time for the 2012 season was about to be won, possibly as early as today.
    A source within the Mountaineer athletic department said on Tuesday that the matter was nearing a conclusion and also told the Times West Virginian that West Virginia would be reinstating a golf team to compete in the Big 12.

    February 8, 2012

  • HERTZEL COLUMN: WVU, Irish strikingly similar

    Consider, if you will, that it is Nov. 25 past, that the West Virginia University basketball team is running a routine drill four games into its season, getting ready for the Akron game when Kevin Jones goes down in a heap on the floor, his ACL torn, his season over.

    February 8, 2012

  • WVU source: Battle to join Big 12 nearing conclusion

    Indications were growing that West Virginia University’s battle to leave the Big East and join the Big 12 in time for the 2012 season was about to be won, possibly as early as today.

    February 7, 2012

  • HERTZEL COLUMN - Truck drives Mountaineers to needed win

    Perhaps it is what has kept him going through a West Virginia basketball career with as many turns as a trip to Pineville down in Wyoming County, but Truck Bryant enjoys being Truck Bryant.

    February 6, 2012

  • WVU finds a way, wins in overtime

    Truck Bryant made the headline plays, including a 3-point shot with 3.3 seconds left to play, as West Virginia saved its season with an 87-84 overtime victory at Providence, but the subheads had to be reserved for Deniz Kilicli and a pair of freshman guards.

    February 6, 2012

  • Mountaineers face critical test today at Providence

    The schedule tells you it’s another game in the marathon run that is the Big East season, a trip to Providence to play a team with only two conference victories, but somehow everyone connected with the West Virginia University program knows today’s noon meeting with the Friars is much more than that.

    February 5, 2012

  • HERTZEL COLUMN: Jones on the brink of WVU history

    On the one hand there is yesterday’s Warren Baker, who entered the WVU Athletic Hall of Fame in the latest class for the work he did from 1973 to 1976, and on the other hand there is today’s star Kevin Jones, who has emerged from the shadows of the likes of Joe Alexander and Da’Sean Butler this year to carve his own niche in Mountaineer basketball history.

    February 5, 2012

  • WVU backs out of Florida State game

    West Virginia University has canceled its Sept. 8 football game at Florida State.
    Once again, as they have done with virtually everything since announcing they planned to move from the Big East to the Big 12, they did it behind closed doors, without any announcement or statement.

    February 5, 2012

  • WVU women upset Louisville

    It is foolhardy to put it up there with the Baylors and Notre Dames of the women’s world just yet, but really if you look closely and see potential, much of which came out Saturday afternoon when the Mountaineers upset No. 12/14 Louisville, 66-50, you realize that this team is closer to greatness than it is to mediocrity.

    February 5, 2012