CHARLESTON — A federal judge has temporarily blocked a West Virginia election law that regulated third-party expenditures and broadcasts of political advertising.
This spring, a federal judge blocked the state from requiring third parties to report what they spent on non-broadcast ads. Lawmakers responded last month by modifying the law, but on Friday U.S. District Judge Thomas Johnston issued an order that temporarily blocked those changes.
In his order, Johnston called parts of the new law unconstitutionally vague.
House Minority Leader Tim Armstead said he was not surprised since opponents of the bill thought it was unconstitutional when it was approved during June’s special session.
“Certainly we had those concerns when the bill was brought before the Legislature,” said Armstead, R-Kanawha. “I think we all felt we were all for disclosure but we wanted the type of disclosure that would hold constitutional scrutiny.”
Johnston’s order blocks the state from barring corporation-funded ads that use “express advocacy” as defined as language that “When considered in its entirety, the communication can only be interpreted by a reasonable person as advocating the election or defeat of one or more clearly identified candidates.”
The order does allow the state to bar corporation-funded ads that employ “express advocacy” through phrases such as “vote for the Governor,” “re-elect your Senator” or “support the Democratic nominee for Supreme Court.”
As with the federal ruling issued in April, Johnston’s order rolls back the disclosure requirement for election-time ads to spots that air on radio and broadcast, cable and satellite TV.
Lawyers for the Center for Individual Freedom and West Virginians for Life challenged the law. Each filed separate lawsuits, since consolidated, against Secretary of State Betty Ireland, as the chief elections office, and a representative county prosecutor, to prevent enforcement.
Both groups want to weigh in on the state Supreme Court race, while the center has also targeted state Attorney General Darrell McGraw in prior ads. But each said they would not if they had to disclose their contributors.
“The wise judge has confirmed CFIF’s position that the two central elements of the effort to suppress free speech during this election both are unconstitutional,” said Thomas W. Kirby, who represents the center. “That will not surprise anyone who regards free speech as a basic right and an essential part of how free people govern themselves.”
State Supreme Court candidates, Democrats Margaret Workman and Menis Ketchum, intervened in the case. The center had sought to advertise in their race, while the anti-abortion group sought to target Workman with its ads.
“My clients are happy that the court rejected the attempts to completely overturn West Virginia’s campaign finance statues,” their lawyer Anthony Majestro said. “However, we’re disappointed that the court refused to enforce the provisions of the statue requiring disclosure of the sources of funding with third-party communications made in non-broadcast media.”
House Judiciary Chairwoman Carrie Webster, D-Kanawha, said the ruling was “a blow to the notion that our elections should be clean and free of fraud and deceit.
“We’re going to continue seeing more and more contributions come in from out of state groups and we’re never going to know who they are and how much they’re spending,” Webster said.
West Virginia
Judge temporarily blocks state election law
Regulating third-party expenditures, broadcasts of political advertising
- West Virginia
-
-
Three aging state power plants to close
FirstEnergy Corp. announced Wednesday it will shut down three aging coal-fired power plants in West Virginia later this year.
The company’s Monongahela Power subsidiary will retire the Albright, Willow Island and Rivesville power stations by Sept. 1, affecting a total of 105 workers. -
Bills would ban children from tanning, tattoos
West Virginia lawmakers are looking to protect children from unhealthy decisions and to give parents more say in their children’s body art choices.
Bills moving through the Legislature would set the minimum age minors can receive their first tattoo and would ban indoor tanning for all children. -
Hackers post officers’ personal information
Hackers affiliated with the group Anonymous obtained personal information for more than 150 police officers from an old website of the West Virginia Chiefs of Police Association and posted the data online.
The FBI is investigating, said William Roper, the association’s president and the police chief of Ranson said. -
Bill would clarify secretary of state’s power
A West Virginia legislator wants state law to say clearly that the secretary of state has the authority to verify whether candidates running for election are eligible to hold office.
Sen. Clark Barnes, R-Randolph, introduced a bill Tuesday that would allow the secretary to refuse to certify candidates and keep them off the ballot if they don’t meet all the legal and constitutional requirements to serve. -
USDA kills 8 coyotes at University Town Centre
U.S. Department of Agriculture employees have killed eight coyotes in a hilltop shopping center complex near Morgantown. They aren’t sure how many remain nearby.
-
Texting bill evolves, heads to House
West Virginia drivers could get a ticket for texting or talking on their cellphone while driving under a bill the Senate unanimously approved Monday.
-
W.Va. texting bill evolves, heads to House
The Senate has approved a bill that would allow police to ticket drivers for texting or talking on their cellphones while on the road.
-
Report: Residents lacking savings
A nonprofit group says nearly one in five West Virginia residents have almost no savings or other assets to weather a financial crisis.
-
Lawmakers navigate lobby ban, social media
In this era of Twitter and smartphones, citizens and lobbyists alike have all sorts of ways to reach out to lawmakers at a moment’s notice. But the West Virginia Legislature has rules meant to insulate its members from last-minute pressures while they’re debating and voting on bills.
-
Firm shows off ‘Guardian Angel’ for miners
A West Virginia company is working on a piece of equipment designed to keep miners safer.
Trinity Resources, headquartered in Putnam County, demonstrated its a mobile mine safety chamber this week at the West Virginia Mining Symposium in Charleston. - More West Virginia Headlines
-
Three aging state power plants to close
