CHARLESTON — The city of Charleston finds itself caught between the Fraternal Order of Police and the state’s largest newspaper over officer time sheets, the city’s lawyer told the Supreme Court Tuesday.
The justices expect to rule by the end of the year on The Charleston Gazette’s request for the records.
The newspaper’s 2007 Freedom of Information Act request for records of 28 officers came amid the convictions of four officers on charges alleging they worked second paid jobs while on duty.
The city initially cited privacy concerns and an ongoing criminal investigation in withholding the records. But the city’s attorney, Ancil Ramey, told the justices Tuesday that the probe ended two weeks ago.
Ramey said the FOP, representing officers, threatened to sue if the records became public. He also said that after denying the request for the records, the city sought guidance from a Kanawha Circuit judge on the relevant law. The abrupt dismissal of that petition prompted the Supreme Court appeal.
Ramey suggested that the justices send the case back to Kanawha County, and allow all interested parties to weigh in before a judge rules. But a lawyer for the Gazette said the law is sufficiently clear to allow the high court to decide the case itself.
“There’s no information that you need,” Sean McGinley told the justices. “These are simple payroll, time sheet records. There’s nothing confidential about them. They’re not personnel records ... There’s no privacy interest.”
McGinley also argued that the city wrongly cited a pair of circuit court orders sealing records of six of the officers, who were then facing criminal indictment, in denying the FOIA request. The city similarly erred by deeming the time sheets part of the “double-dipping” probe, he said.
“This was not something prepared by the police in the course of a criminal investigation,” McGinley said. “These are accounting records, payroll records showing the hours worked by public employees.”
“And paid by public money,” added Chief Justice Elliott “Spike” Maynard.
While conceding that the newspaper may prevail, Ramey later cited a federal ruling out of southern West Virginia that he said did not conclude such timekeeping records were public.
Retired Justice Thomas McHugh heard the case for Justice Joseph Albright, who continues to recover from esophagus surgery.
West Virginia
Court hears police FOIA case
- West Virginia
-
-
Man gets life sentence for ex-wife’s death
A man was sentenced to life in prison with the possibility of parole in the beating death of his ex-wife.
Thomas Charlie Lee Runner, 46, of Galloway, pleaded guilty to first-degree murder Wednesday at the Barbour County Courthouse in Philippi. -
State campaign finance limits challenged in court
A political group formed to aid West Virginia incumbents this November won a partial victory Thursday after suing over the state’s limits on campaign contributions and a policy addressing corporate spending.
-
Relatives other than parents raising kids
Sharon Davis jumped in and obtained custody of her young grandson when her daughter got tangled in a web of drugs. A decade later, her daughter is straightened out and now has her own little girl, while her son remains with Davis.
-
Project aims to get West Virginians active
A new wellness project aims to motivate West Virginians to get off their couches and be healthy.
LiveWell West Virginia is a collaboration of the West Virginia University Extension Service and the Charleston Gazette. -
Missing girl’s mother gets eight months for welfare fraud
A federal judge on Tuesday ordered the mother of a 3-year-old girl who vanished eight months ago this week to spend eight months behind bars for welfare fraud.
U.S. District Judge John Preston Bailey ruled that Lena Lunsford must begin serving her sentence June 28. -
West Virginia seventh in death rates for accidents, violence
Drug overdoses and motor vehicle crashes helped push West Virginia’s death rate involving accidents and violence to the seventh-highest in the nation, according to a report on injury prevention released Tuesday.
-
W.Va. could add hurdles to primary ballot
West Virginia officials have several options if they want to avoid repeating an outcome of this month’s primary election, when imprisoned felon Keith Judd attracted nearly 41 percent of the vote against President Barack Obama.
-
W.Va. could add hurdles to primary ballot
West Virginia officials have several options if they want to avoid a repeat outcome of this month’s primary election, when imprisoned felon Keith Judd attracted nearly 41 percent of the vote against President Barack Obama.
-
Computers used to grade WESTEST essays
Thousands of essays written by West Virginia students are largely going unread by human eyes.
-
West Virginia coal mining employment at high level
State figures show that coal mining employment in West Virginia is at its highest level since the 1990s.
The Charleston Gazette says a recent analysis of Workforce West Virginia figures by Ted Boettner with the West Virginia Center for Budget and Policy shows there were nearly 22,700 mining jobs in 2011. - More West Virginia Headlines
-
Man gets life sentence for ex-wife’s death
