PARKERSBURG — Three scientists working to discover if the chemical known as C8 affects human health won’t have to make their quarterly progress reports public, although a judge says it could be helpful.
Wood County Circuit Judge J.D. Beane said making those reports available through the court would provide valuable information to the public, but he stopped short of ordering it.
Currently, the C8 Science Panel’s quarterly reports are provided to the two parties in a lawsuit that led to the creation of the panel — DuPont Co. and plaintiffs who live within six water districts in the Mid-Ohio Valley.
Lawyers for both parties said in court Thursday that if the scientists discover anything significant before their reports are due, they’re able to make those findings public.
Lawyers for DuPont argued that requiring the panel to file its reports with the court wasn’t specified by the settlement that ended the lawsuit.
“There should be no reason why they should have to file a piece of paper every quarter” if the panel has nothing significant to report, DuPont lawyer Libby Stennes said. “When the science panel has something they want to communicate, they’ll do it.”
Larry Winter, one of the lawyers representing the plaintiffs, said the panel so far has made everything of significance public.
If the panel reaches a finding it wants to communicate immediately, it can submit a report to the plaintiffs and DuPont, and then to the court, Winter said.
The scientists are conducting 10 studies that follow up on a health screening of up to 70,000 Mid-Ohio Valley residents who were part of the class-action lawsuit that claimed C8 releases from DuPont’s Washington Works Plant near Parkersburg contaminated their water supplies.
DuPont agreed to fund the health screening and install carbon filters at six water district filtration plants to screen out the chemical
The question of making the quarterly reports public was raised by Harry Deitzler, one of the lawyers representing the plaintiffs.
Deitzler said the panel and the lawyers regularly receive requests for information from the public and the media.
Initially, the judge seemed to favor the idea.
“The more the public is aware of any issue, the better off we all are,” Beane said. “This is a big issue. I think it would help everyone.”
After hearing from DuPont and Winter, though, Beane did not order the quarterly science reports to be made public.
Though used since World War II, C8’s long-term effects on humans are unknown. DuPont maintains the chemical is not hazardous to human health. A U.S. Environmental Protection Agency science panel has said C8 is a “likely” carcinogenic.
The three-member science panel is reviewing the health histories and blood samples of those residents who participated in the health screening.
The 10 studies will look at health issues such as cancer, heart disease, stroke, diabetes and aneurysm, immune function, liver and hormone disorders, and birth outcomes. Last year, the panel said it could take until 2011 to complete its research.
West Virginia
C8 Science Panel urged to make reports public
- West Virginia
-
-
Tomblin expects miner drug testing approval
Gov. Earl Ray Tomblin said Thursday he believes lawmakers will quickly come to agreement and pass his proposed mine safety legislation, including a provision that calls for mandatory drug testing of coal miners.
-
Autism law in jeopardy, supporters warn
West Virginia’s new law extending health care coverage to children with autism may not do what its supporters intended, and a fight is brewing with insurers over pending legislation on the subject.
-
Main says violations at U.S. coal mines down in 2011
Coal operators across the country are changing the way they work, and mines are becoming safer, but the head of the federal Mine Safety and Health Administration said Thursday there are still too many who “don’t get it.”
-
‘Cracker’ chase enters waiting phase
West Virginia’s hunt for a multibillion-dollar chemical plant has come down to talks between potential investors and private property owners, Commerce Secretary Keith Burdette said Thursday.
Burdette told The Associated Press that the two companies that each want to build a massive “cracker” facility in the Marcellus shale region are negotiating with owners of potential sites. -
Fix for W.Va. retiree health costs passes Senate
West Virginia’s Senate moved Wednesday to tackle one of the state’s biggest funding shortfalls, a $5 billion liability stemming from public retiree health care costs, unanimously passing a proposal from Gov. Earl Ray Tomblin.
-
MSHA officials: U.S. coal mine safety is improving
Federal regulators said Wednesday the nation’s coal mines have made huge strides in safety, pointing to a dramatic reduction in the number of accidents and injuries in the nation’s single largest district in southern West Virginia.
-
Three states offer big tax breaks to lure Shell Oil plant to region
Pennsylvania, Ohio and West Virginia are trying to top each other with the sweetest package of tax breaks for Shell Oil Co., which plans to build a huge new petrochemical refinery in the region.
But some are questioning why there’s been so little public discussion over exactly what’s being offered, and how the deals would impact communities and the region. -
W.Va. Senate kills bill on magistrate education
The Senate killed a bill that would require elected magistrates to earn at least an associate’s degree, likely ending efforts this year to increase education requirements for the officials.
-
Penn State scandal spurs sex abuse bills
All adult West Virginians would be required to report suspected sexual abuse to the police under a bill working its way through the Legislature.
-
Lack of candidates will shape many W.Va. legislative races
West Virginia ended its candidate filing period Saturday, but the results of more than 50 of this year’s legislative races are already largely decided, according to a review by The Associated Press.
- More West Virginia Headlines
-
Tomblin expects miner drug testing approval
