PITTSBURGH —
Clint Hurdle is rarely at a loss for words. Yet even the normally chatty Pittsburgh Pirates manager had problems describing what happened in a gaffe-filled 12-2 loss to the Chicago Cubs on Friday night.
Pittsburgh committed seven errors during the franchise’s worst defensive game in more than a quarter-century to blunt its push for a playoff spot.
“I’ve never been part of a game with seven errors, that’s a new one,” Hurdle said. “There’s nobody in there that’s not embarrassed to some degree.”
Rookie outfielder Starling Marte and rookie second baseman Brock Holt committed two errors each while catcher Rod Barajas, first baseman Gaby Sanchez and shortstop Josh Harrison also botched makeable plays.
“It was just one of those games, words can’t even really describe it,” Harrison said. “I really don’t know what to say but put it behind us and come back tomorrow.”
Pittsburgh starter A.J. Burnett had been lights out against the Cubs during his career. He came in 6-0 lifetime against Chicago and hadn’t even given up a run to the woeful Cubs in two starts with Pittsburgh this season.
All the history didn’t matter, however, on a night the Pirates provided Chicago with extra out after extra out. Burnett (15-6) allowed seven runs — three earned — and eight hits in five innings. He struck out four and walked one.
Chicago’s Travis Wood had no such issues. The left-hander won for the first time in more than two months as the Cubs snapped a six-game losing streak.
“The pitches were working good and the defense was outstanding behind me,” Wood said, who improved to 5-12 after allowing one hit in six innings.
The Pirates, not so much.
Playing meaningful September baseball for the first time in 20 years, Pittsburgh hardly looked like a playoff team.
“Our worst game of the season,” said Hurdle, who was ejected in the sixth inning. “We stunk tonight. There’s always a sense of pride you take out on the field to play your best every night you go out there. Sometimes your best stinks. That’s where we were tonight.”
Starlin Castro had three hits, including the 500th of his career, and drove in four runs for the Cubs. Alfonso Soriano added three hits and three RBIs as Chicago took full advantage Pittsburgh’s charitable defense.
The Pirates had not made seven errors in a game since 1985 and finished one shy of the club record set in 1939. It was the first seven-error game in the majors since Atlanta in a 2004 loss to Colorado.
Pittsburgh’s problems started early. Chicago took a 1-0 lead in the first thanks in part to an error by Holt.
Things quickly got worse.
Chicago made it 4-0 in the third with plenty of assistance from Marte. One of the franchise’s most promising prospects, Marte mishandled a single by Soriano with one on and two outs. The ball caromed off his glove away from him and in his haste to recover, Marte threw wildly in the vicinity of third base.
The ball sailed all the way to the backstop, allowing Anthony Rizzo and Soriano to move into scoring position. Moments later Marte was in trouble again when he booted a sharply hit ball by Castro. Rizzo and Soriano scored easily and Castro — who advanced to second on the error — scored on Steve Clevenger’s single.
“It was nice to come in here against one of the better teams in the National League and put it on them pretty good,” Chicago manager Dale Sveum said. “That was good for us, especially from where we were just coming from and for the mental state of the guys in that clubhouse.”
Hurdle tried to give his team some life, getting thrown out for the fourth time this season for arguing a close play at third base in which umpire Gary Darling ruled Chicago’s Brett Jackson beat Harrison’s throw on a fielders’ choice.
Instead of responding, the Pirates collapsed as the Cubs eventually went up by a dozen.
At one point a fan in an exasperated PNC Park crowd started yelling “Error! Error!” at the official scorer on a cleanly hit single by Chicago’s Tony Campana in the eighth.
Instead of history, the Pirates finished with only seven errors, the most since an 8-4 loss to St. Louis on Sept. 16, 1985.
“We have a very resilient team, but at the same time when you go through that, it stings,” Hurdle said. “We talk a lot about things in this game being contagious, on the defensive side, it was.”
Wood, who hadn’t won since beating the Mets on July 6, didn’t let the good fortune go to waste. He retired 14 of the first 15 batters he faced and didn’t give up a hit until the fifth when Pedro Alvarez’s flyball to center glanced off Jackson’s glove as the outfielder smacked into the wall.
NOTES: Castro became the 28th player in major league history to reach 500 hits before his 23rd birthday. The previous player to do it was Alex Rodriguez ... The series continues Saturday. Chicago’s Jeff Samardzija (8-13, 3.91 ERA) will make his final start of the season for the Cubs against Pittsburgh’s James McDonald (12-7, 3.90).
Pirates
Pirates commit 7 errors in 12-2 loss to Cubs
- Pirates
-
-
Pirates beat Cubs, 5-4, behind Snider’s grand slam
Travis Snider hit a pinch-hit grand slam during a five-run sixth and the Pittsburgh Pirates spoiled a strong return to the mound for Matt Garza with a 5-4 win over the Chicago Cubs on Tuesday night.
-
Locke, Pirates shut down Astros, 1-0
Jeff Locke didn’t have his best stuff Sunday. He didn’t need it to shut down the majors’ worst team.
-
Astros edge Pirates 4-2 in 11 innings
The Pittsburgh Pirates’ bullpen had been automatic with late-inning leads. Until Saturday night.
Jason Castro led off the 11th inning with a double and scored the go-ahead run on a close play at the plate as the Houston Astros topped the Pirates 4-2. -
Dropped fly ball gives Pirates 5-4 win over Astros
Jimmy Paredes dropped Russell Martin’s bases-loaded fly ball when he collided with second baseman Jake Elmore with two outs in the ninth inning, the second missed catch by a Houston right fielder, and the Pittsburgh Pirates rallied past the Astros 5-4 Friday night.
-
Snider powers Pirates past Brewers, 7-1
Travis Snider homered for the first time in nine months and drove in three runs to lead the Pittsburgh Pirates past the reeling Milwaukee Brewers 7-1 on Thursday night.
Snider finished 3 for 5, including a 458-foot blast off Hiram Burgos (1-2) in the sixth inning that gave the Pirates the lead. -
Rodriguez, Pirates silence Brewers, 3-1
Wandy Rodriguez allowed one run over seven strong innings and Neil Walker hit a two-run single as the Pittsburgh Pirates beat the Milwaukee Brewers 3-1 on Wednesday night.
Rodriguez (4-2) gave up six hits, walking one and striking out five. -
McCutchen homers in 12th as Pirates top Brewers
Andrew McCutchen homered leading off the bottom of the 12th inning to lift the Pittsburgh Pirates to a 4-3 victory over the Milwaukee Brewers on Tuesday night.
-
Brewers snap skid, drop sloppy Pirates, 5-1
Marco Estrada allowed three hits over seven innings and the Milwaukee Brewers beat the sloppy Pittsburgh Pirates 5-1 on Monday night to snap a four-game losing streak.
-
Pirates get fortunate bounce to beat Mets, 3-2
Reliever Mark Melancon said his heart sunk. Second baseman Brandon Inge figured, that’s it, two runs. Pedro Alvarez watched from third base and tossed his head back, disappointed.
-
Liriano fans nine as Pirates top Mets
Francisco Liriano finally got to pitch for Pittsburgh and, just like that, the Pirates looked like a much better team.
He struck out nine and the Pirates teed off on New York’s pitching for an 11-2 win over the Mets on Saturday. - More Pirates Headlines
-
Pirates beat Cubs, 5-4, behind Snider’s grand slam


