FAIRMONT — A unanimous decision by the state Supreme Court rejecting a lawsuit by Marion County Commission President Alan Parks challenging whether his Democratic opponent met residency requirements has left unanswered some legal issues, lawyers said.
But the high court’s action on Thursday has ended the controversy in the county, principals on both sides said Friday.
The court did not say why it voted 5-0 in a private conference not to hear Parks’ suit. In a Friday order, the court said only that his request for a writ of mandamus was refused.
Tim Manchin, a lawyer defending Burley “Butch” Tennant Jr., said a “fair interpretation” of the court’s vote is that it agrees with Tennant.
Parks said Friday he’s dropping his legal challenge. He had argued that Tennant didn’t establish his residency in the Middletown magisterial district until after the May 13 primary.
But according to Manchin and lawyers for the county’s election officials as well as the county’s Democratic party, Parks was trying to use the courts to remove any opposition at all in the general election.
Parks’ petition to the high court was filed after a deadline for allowing Democrats to name a replacement candidate, they argued.
Parks and the county commission began checking into whether Tennant met the residency requirement in January. The county commission spent $3,000 for legal advice from Fairmont lawyer Jeffrey Lilly.
But the commission never took any legal action. Instead, Parks hired Lilly and filed his own suit late last month.
Removing Tennant now, after the ballots had been printed and after absentee ballots had been mailed to voters, would have created turmoil, Tennant’s lawyers said.
And, they argued, it would deny the public a choice of candidates.
Manchin said the high court may agree that a candidate can meet the residency requirement by living in a contested district by the date of the general election — and not by the date of the primary. There are two previous rulings by the high court. One sets the primary date as the requirement; the other picks the general election date.
“But we admitted all of the other sides’ facts on the residency question, where he (Tennant) lived and when,” Manchin said.
In October 2007, two months before he filed to run in the Democratic primary, Tennant sought advice from the Secretary of State’s office.
Later that month, the Secretary of State’s office sent him a letter stating that a candidate had to reside within the district in question on the date of the general election, Tennant said.
Tennant resigned a seat he had held for seven-and-a-half years on Fairmont City Council. He moved last summer from his home in the Palatine District to one on Sylvan Street in the Middletown District.
Or, Manchin said, the court may agree with another central defense tenet: Parks waited too long to file his suit.
Questions about Tennant’s residency were raised in January, when candidates file to run in the primary. Referring to the commission’s hiring of Lilly, Manchin said the commission was also well aware of the issue.
It’s known as the legal doctrine of laches, he said: “You can’t sit on your rights to try to help yourself.”
E-mail Bill Byrd at bbyrd@timeswv.com.
Local News
Court decision ends battle over residency
No reason given on why it voted 5-0 in private conference not to hear Parks’ suit
- Local News
-
-
Teaching on their level
“I would like to nominate Lois Thibodeau for ‘My Favorite Teacher.’ She is the special needs Pre-K teacher at Watson Elementary School.” This was Kristi Wolford singing the praises of Lois Thibodeau.
-
DHHR requiring additional vaccines for students
Seventh- and 12th-graders who return to class in the fall without certain immunizations will not be allowed to attend school unless they get the required inoculations.
-
Cost of crime
Victim.
You never thought this would be you.
But you are the victim of a nonviolent or violent crime.
After contacting the proper authorities, you may be bewildered as to what happens next. -
More streets to be paved this week
Even more city streets will be paved this week than expected.
City Manager Jay Rogers said the spring paving required fewer tons of asphalt to cover the distance than originally estimated. That means there’s asphalt to spare and more streets are getting paved this spring. -
Bertoletti has 33 pepperoni rolls in only 10 minutes to win
If there’s one Memorial Day tradition that everybody participates in, one way or another, it’s eating.
Maybe it’s at a picnic at one of the many venues scattered across Marion County, enjoying hamburgers, hot dogs, macaroni salad and other seasonal food. -
Assaults, physical or not, affect ‘sense of safety and trust’
An assault of any kind — whether it’s physical or not — can be traumatizing.
“You don’t need to have suffered any cuts or scratches,” said Dr. Ronald Pearse, “but any kind of assault affects your sense of safety and trust.” -
Reasoning Mind excites students
As a teacher, Beverly Stewart has never been more thrilled than when she sees the benefits a newer program has done for her students.
Pleasant Valley Elementary fifth-grade student Calista Muzzapelle worked diligently on her assignments last week, much like she had during her Christmas break. -
Pepperoni roll prize
To someone from out of state, the pepperoni roll might seem like a mystery.
“Is it like a calzone?” they might ask, “or a stromboli?”
Unique to the state of West Virginia, the pepperoni roll represents the Italian heritage of many of the miners in the early 20th century mixed with hardworking Mountaineer common sense. -
BOE seeks land for new middle schools
The Marion County Board of Education is looking at land to build new middle schools in Mannington and Monongah.
If all goes as planned, county voters will see a bond on the November ballot. -
Former WVU coach takes final journey home
Bill Stewart has made his way back home.
The former West Virginia University football coach, who died suddenly earlier this week of a heart attack at 59, was laid to rest Friday in his hometown of New Martinsville. - More Local News Headlines
-
