FAIRMONT — A conflict between the Rivesville council and former recorder and town resident John Harless has escalated to circuit court.
Judge David R. Janes heard both sides of the case Thursday, which dealt with several Freedom of Information Act requests filed by Harless concerning Rivesville records. The requests were made for various financial documents, such as the town’s check registry. Harless also sent requests for profit-and-loss financial statements for each of the town’s departments.
Harless had received copies of the check registry. However, the names of the people the checks were made out to had been blacked out. The memo section of the checks had also been blacked out because they had Social Security numbers written on them, according to DeAndra Burton, Rivesville town attorney.
Janes ruled in favor of Harless, ordering the town officials to provide the records to the Rivesville resident. The judge informed the council members who were present at the hearing to provide Harless with copies of the town’s check registry among the numerous other records that were requested.
“This information that Mr. Harless has requested, as painful as it is, is public information,” Janes said after his ruling.
“You can redact (black out) the Social Security numbers, but not the names on the checks,” Janes said.
Janes also ruled that the council members could not charge more than 25 cents per page for copies of the documents provided to Harless. Rivesville officials recently passed an ordinance requiring that a fee of 75 cents per page for copies would be levied for all information requested from the town records.
“I think that today, 25 cents is a reasonable fee,” Janes said.
Rivesville officials are also required to reimburse Harless for court costs, Janes said. Harless did not hire a lawyer and instead represented himself at the proceedings so council does not have to reimburse him for attorney fees. Janes added that the court costs will probably cost the town approximately $205.
“I think the hearing went well,” said Harless following the proceedings. “And I am satisfied with what I received.”
Tammie Crites, Rivesville mayor, said that she did not disagree with the ruling. However, she added that she did not believe the FOIA requests from Harless would stop now that the case has been decided.
“I think that we’ll continue to be barraged with FOIA requests by Mr. Harless to no constructive purpose,” Crites said.
Crites, along with Burton, added that they had believed at the time that they were protecting the privacy of town employees when they redacted the names from the copy of the check registry provided to Harless. The two insisted that they did not intentionally try to hide financial information from him.
Harless had originally filed suit against both Crites and Barb Beatty, town recorder, in both their official capacity as well as personally. Janes had dismissed the suit against the two in their personal capacity.
E-mail Paul Fallon at pfallon@timeswv.com.
In Today's TWV
February 15, 2008
Judge orders Rivesville officials to provide records
- In Today's TWV
-
-
US kills Osama bin Laden decade after 9/11 attacks
Osama bin Laden, the face of global terrorism and architect of the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks, was killed in a firefight with elite American forces Monday, then quickly buried at sea in a stunning finale to a furtive decade on the run.
-
Construction around FSU
Construction matters were on the minds of the Fairmont State Board of Governors Thursday as they discussed projects to widen Locust Avenue and the continuing renovation of the historic Kennedy Barn.
First, a project to widen Locust Avenue to three lanes has been a priority for the state for several years. -
Goal: Redevelop site of former black Elks
City officials are hoping to solicit a buyer to redevelop the former site of the former black Elks building at the corner of Everest Drive and Cleveland Avenue.
Following the structure’s emergency demolition last weekend, city manager Jim Snider said the city is hoping someone will come forward to develop the site and recoup the city’s $72,000 demolition cost. -
Investigation continues into suspicious container, plastic jug that were blown up
Fairmont police detectives will continue their investigation into a suspicious can and jug that were blown up late Friday night by a State Police bomb squad, police said.
No one was injured, but the incident forced drivers to detour around Fairmont Avenue from Seventh to 10th streets while the area was secured and the containers were safely destroyed. -
Years of planning, work lead to new Baxter fire hall
In 1968, the Baxter Volunteer Fire Department opened its doors for the first time.
The department had its humble beginnings in a small pole building near the ball field. Over the years, the firefighters made do with the small building, adding on as they could, according to Destry Jones, Baxter fire chief. -
AmberView participation rising
Fairview Middle School has a higher percentage of students enrolled in AmberView than any other school in the state, officials said Friday.
AmberView is an innovative program, developed in West Virginia, that assists law enforcement by quickly issuing an up-to-date digital picture of a missing or abducted child. AmberView officials have seen participation rise dramatically in the last year. -
Police investigate, detonate suspected bomb
West Side’s main thoroughfare was blocked for hours while police investigated and then detonated a suspected bomb Friday night.
Fairmont City Police responded to a report of a suspicious package Friday after a 911 call from a passerby. -
Student housing at FSU booming
While enrollment may be down at Fairmont State this year, student housing is booming.
The university’s board of governors received preliminary enrollment numbers at its meeting Thursday. -
Jay to speak at convention
U.S. Sen. Jay Rockefeller, an early supporter of Sen. Barack Obama, will be a speaker at the Democratic National Convention in Denver later this month, a campaign aide said.
Rockefeller, 71, who is seeking a fifth-straight term in the Senate, will speak on Wednesday, Aug. 27, said Jessica Tice, his campaign press secretary. -
A strong ‘heartbeat’
“The chamber is the heartbeat of every community,” Gov. Joe Manchin told a crowd of approximately 375 people during the Marion County Chamber of Commerce’s 55th Annual Dinner.
Members of the business community gathered at Fairmont State University’s Falcon Center Thursday night for the event, which also serves as the chamber’s annual meeting. - More In Today's TWV Headlines
-
US kills Osama bin Laden decade after 9/11 attacks
