WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court stepped into a sensitive dispute Friday over a state judge’s decision to participate in a case that involved a key campaign supporter.
The justices typically avoid cases about judicial ethics, but they agreed to review the actions of a West Virginia Supreme Court justice whose vote overturned a $50 million verdict against a company that is run by the most generous backer of his election.
The high court’s decision comes amid growing concern over the role of money in electing state judges. Campaign spending on state supreme court elections rose by 25 percent to nearly $20 million from 2006 to 2008, a national justice reform group said.
Don Blankenship, the chief executive of Massey Energy Co., spent more than $3 million to help elect Justice Brent Benjamin to the West Virginia high court. Benjamin twice was part of 3-2 majorities that threw out a verdict in favor of Harman Mining Co. in its coal contract dispute with Massey.
Harman said Benjamin’s participation in the case created an appearance of bias strong enough to violate its constitutional rights.
The American Bar Assocation and other legal ethics groups have taken Harman’s side.
In earlier cases, the Supreme Court has said that judges must avoid even the appearance of bias.
Benjamin repeatedly rejected calls to recuse himself from the case when it was before the state high court. He has since said that he fairly judged the dispute.
Benjamin issued a lengthy defense of his actions, pointing out that he had no financial interest in the outcome of the case and the campaign money went to an independent group, not his campaign. He had no comment Friday after the court accepted the case for review.
Massey vice president and general counsel Shane Harvey said, “We are confident that the Harman case was properly decided by the West Virginia Supreme Court.”
David Fawcett, a Pittsburgh attorney who represents Harman and its founder, Hugh Caperton, said, “The question at issue here is central to the future of our court system.” Former Solicitor General Theodore Olson will argue the case for Caperton at the Supreme Court, probably in March or April.
Retired Supreme Court Justice Sandra Day O’Connor has not commented on the West Virginia dispute, but she has bemoaned the role of money in state judicial elections.
“There is too much special interest money and influence in state court elections,” O’Connor said recently. “It endangers the public’s faith in the justice system. If courts are going to stay impartial, leaders in every state need to get moving on reforms.”
Former Colorado Supreme Court Justice Rebecca Love Kourlis, an advocate for ending partisan election of judges, said the case may get “people to pay attention to the problems partisan fundraising creates.” Kourlis is executive director of the Institute for the Advancement of the American Legal System at the University of Denver, which provided the figures on spending in judicial elections.
The Supreme Court case stems from a jury verdict in 2002 that concluded Richmond, Va.-based Massey hijacked a coal supply contract from Harman, plunging both it and Caperton into bankruptcy.
Massey contended Harman filed for bankruptcy because of mounting losses at a mining facility and other problems that had nothing to do with Massey.
The case is Caperton v. Massey, 08-22.
Headline News
High court to rule when judges must step aside
- Headline News
-
-
Many new veterans seeking disability
America’s newest veterans are filing for disability benefits at a historic rate, claiming to be the most medically and mentally troubled generation of former troops the nation has ever seen.
-
Driving season begins, as does griping about gas prices
It’s Memorial Day weekend and our national obsession with the price of gasoline is in focus once again.
-
Road to 270
President Barack Obama faces new warning signs in a once-promising Southern state and typically Democratic-voting Midwestern states roughly five months before the election even as he benefits nationally from encouraging economic news.
-
Obama, Romney trying to play it safe
In the risky business of running for president, Barack Obama and Mitt Romney are largely playing it safe.
For all the small daily dramas of the 2012 campaign, there’s a risk-averse dynamic playing out: Neither candidate has been making bold new policy proposals or displaying a free-wheeling personal style. So far, at least. -
Travelers to hit the road this weekend
More Americans will hit the road this holiday weekend than a year ago. And they’ll have a bit more money to spend thanks to lower gas prices.
Memorial Day kicks off the summer travel season, and since pump prices never reached $4 or $5 a gallon as feared, economists say travelers are likely to dine out or shop more once they pull off the road. -
Man charged with murdering boy in 1979
Thirty-three years to the day after 6-year-old Etan Patz vanished without a trace while walking to catch a school bus, a man accused of strangling him and dumping his body with the trash was arraigned on a murder charge on Friday in a locked hospital ward where he was being held as a suicide risk.
-
States looking to new tolls to pay for highways
Driving onto an Interstate highway? Crossing a bridge on the way into work? Taking a tunnel under a river or bay? Get ready to pay.
-
Secret Service misbehavior detailed
Senators investigating the Secret Service prostitution scandal said Wednesday that dozens of reported episodes of misconduct by agents point to a culture of carousing in the agency and urged Director Mark Sullivan to get past his insistence that the romp in Cartagena was a one-time mistake.
-
U.S. Army selective on recruits, re-enlistment
Uncle Sam may not want you after all.
In sharp contrast to the peak years of the Iraq and Afghanistan wars, the Army last year took in no recruits with misconduct convictions or drug or alcohol issues, according to internal documents obtained by The Associated Press. -
Joplin remembers deadly tornado
Carrying small American flags and wearing T-shirts bearing the names of friends and loved ones who died when a massive tornado tore through Joplin one year ago, thousands of people made a somber march Tuesday through some of the town’s hardest-hit neighborhoods.
- More Headline News Headlines
-
Many new veterans seeking disability
