Opinion
Would ‘bottle bill’ discourage littering?
As a child in Oregon, a state where you have to pay a nickle extra if you want a pop, the Poe kids sure loved Saturday morning.
On Saturday, we headed out in the early morning with bags and hit the park near our house. We collected cans and bottles left over from “parties” the night before and headed toward the grocery store, picking up cans along the way. By the time we got to the grocery store, we had quite a bit of cans in our bags. In fact, we usually had enough to watch a matinee. I don’t remember any of the movies, but I sure do remember getting all of those cans. Being the youngest, I was sometimes designated to maneuver into tight places to grab a can, under a bush or some other place I’m sure my mother wouldn’t approve of.
The nickle deposits, still in effect today, were an effort to reduce litter and refuse and to promote recycling in a state that practically invented the Green Movement. But it didn’t matter much to those who partied on Friday nights and found the most convenient place to stash a can was the side of the road or under a picnic table. Oh well, their stash was our cash.
I’m not the only one who has memories like that.
And online poster to our community forum, known only as “cuzanbill,” remembers doing that same thing as a child here in Marion County.
“Before plastic became so popular, most beverages came in glass bottles — especially milk and pop had a deposit on them,” Bill writes. “You either carried back empties to the store or paid deposit on your new purchase. As a kid in the 1950s, I made my candy money collecting pop bottles from along the roadside where the deposit payers had tossed them.
“On a good day, I might make a couple of dollars at 3 cents a bottle. That was 3 cents a bottle when the pop was 5 to 10 cents a bottle,” he writes.
So now that legislators are considering a deposit on cans and bottles again — this time 10 cents — some people don’t think that a “bottle bill” will discourage littering and promote recycling.
“It didn’t back then!” Bill writes.
Another online fan, Fairmont native Mike Koval, who now lives in Ft. Meyers, Fla., doesn’t buy into the whole bottle bill either.
“I do not see the bottle/can deposit cutting down on litter,” Koval said in an e-mail to me sent last week. “Slovenly types will continue to toss the stuff out the window because ‘it is only one can, one bottle, or one piece of paper’ or ‘let someone else clean it up.’ Too lazy to put it in the garbage can when they arrive at their destination.
“ I see the deposit as another tax,” Mike says.
It was a pretty even split among our voters last week when we asked them on our online poll their thoughts about establishing a bottle bill here in West Virginia.
Some people don’t feel like the bill is necessary — they are already faithful recyclers. Coming in at 28.46 percent of the vote was, “I don’t need a dime to convince me to recycle. There’s a blue box on my curb every week.”
With a little bigger chunk of the vote were the ones who believe a bill like this will make a better world for future generations. With 31.71 percent of the vote was, “I support anything that will help me reduce my environmental footprint.” Hey, a can is a can — and it’s always a can unless it’s recycled.
With just a few more votes were the ones who think, like Bill and Mike, that the effort won’t be worth the effect. With a total of 39.84 percent of the vote was, “In the end, it will cost the state too much in administration costs for what it will bring in.”
Well, we have a bit more time to see whether 21st century kids will get a chance to see a matinee on someone else’s dime.
This week, let’s talk about the I-79 Gateway Connector. Now that there’s visible progress being made, what do you think the next development will be?
Log on. Vote. E-mail me.
Misty Poe
City Editor
mpoe@timeswv.com
- Opinion
-
-
Labor: Our stabilizing and strengthening force for good
The most grandiose idea birthed in the mind of a brilliant professional will forever remain dormant and useless until it reaches the productive hands of labor.
The American labor force has distinguished itself from generation to generation for its ability to produce, with accuracy and dependability, any task it was given. -
‘The Cure’ for economy remains elusive
When you’ve got a nasty cold, it seems like everyone has The Cure and you’ve just got to try it.
A hot toddy.
Chicken soup and cough syrup.
Orange juice and plenty of rest.
And maybe you’ve tried them a time or two. And, in some cases, The Cure eases the symptoms, but it never makes the cold go away. -
Supercomputer ‘beacon’ builds credibility of I-79 High Tech Corridor
We don’t just consider the announcement of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration’s latest project as one more piece of the I-79 Technology Park puzzle.
When the West Virginia High Tech Consortium announced this week that NOAA would be building a supercomputer in Fairmont at the high-tech park, a lot of words came to mind, but one in particular.
Beacon. -
Love of helping students propels FSHS principal to state recognition
Chad Norman, principal of Fairmont Senior High School, believes that one of the most important aspects of being in his position is loving the students under his guidance.
He says “you have to love to work with kids. And I do love working with them, spending time with them, helping to mold and shape them.” -
New nuisance ordinance will give residents peace and quiet
We’ve all been there.
The neighbors are playing their music at a high volume. So high, in fact, that you can hear the lyrics as plainly as if the music were playing in your own home. It’s getting late, and you’ve got a long day ahead. The police are called, but they can do nothing because of ineffective laws that prohibit citations from being issued. -
Ethics law’s ‘revolving door’ should be reviewed
West Virginia’s governmental ethics law — like its counterpart in nearly every state — bans the “revolving door” custom through which state officials deal with private firms, then resign to take lucrative jobs with the same firms, or quit to become lobbyists pressuring their former colleagues. Somehow, this practice seems too cozy to be desirable.
-
It’s time ‘brick wall’ Greater Marion PSD customers have hit finally is taken down
It’s a situation no one should have to deal with for a day.
Let alone a decade.
Carolina, Idamay and Kellytown residents are still waiting for groundbreaking on a project to grant them relief from numerous sewage system issues that have been plaguing the small communities for years. -
‘Ground Zero Mosque’ sparks big debate
It is perhaps the biggest debate to hit the nation involving the Islamic faith since the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, 2001, when radical extremists were responsible for the deaths of thousands in New York City, Southwestern Pennsylvania and Washington, D.C.
-
Let your voice be heard at polls during primary for Senate seat
What are you doing on Saturday?
It’s the last weekend in August. Next weekend is set aside for Labor Day. That’s the last weekend of the summer. But what are you doing this weekend?
Maybe going swimming? Perhaps going shopping? Or maybe going out of town this weekend and staying home for the Mountaineer football game next weekend? You could have a picnic planned. -
Head injuries must never be taken lightly at any level
It’s time for the lights to go on Friday night in stadiums across the state.
- More Opinion Headlines
-
Labor: Our stabilizing and strengthening force for good
