The Associated Press has reported that more than 2,400 jobs have been saved or created in West Virginia because of federal stimulus funding.
These figures come from those individuals who have been spending the money.
But is that really a figure that we are proud of? Let’s examine the figures.
They indicate that federal officials have reviewed hundreds of reports filed last month by stimulus beneficiaries. They include state and local government agencies as well as private sector contractors and nonprofit groups.
About two-thirds of the 2,400 jobs created or saved came from state agencies that spent $250 million. That’s about 1,600 jobs. About 20 percent were in education, according to numbers provided from the Manchin administration.
The next-largest share resulted from spending on Workforce Investment Act programs, which offer training and other employment services. Another 16 percent came from road and bridge projects fueled by stimulus dollars, the administration figures said.
“I think we’ve gotten a really good return on our dollars so far,” said Jim Pitrolo, Gov. Joe Manchin’s legislative director. “The best value so far has been the increased funding for Medicaid and the highway spending.” The state’s unemployment rate remains below the national average, and Pitrolo noted that West Virginia has relied on fewer stimulus dollars than most other states so far to keep its budgets balanced.
“I don’t think that comparison is fair to West Virginia because West Virginia was lucky enough not to need much money up front,” he said.
West Virginia ranks 41st in creating jobs with stimulus funds ... not a very good ranking. But on the other hand, you must consider that West Virginia was not hit as hard as many other states and it still maintains one of the lowest unemployment rates in the nation. That’s fewer jobs to create or replace.
Now let’s look at the other side of the picture.
There are areas where we can see that the money spent, plus the jobs that were created, doesn’t seem to equal good value. For example, each of the 321 education jobs attributed to the stimulus “cost” around $10,000.
But as far as highways and roads projects jobs created, $36 million was spent and 251 jobs were created. That totals to about $143,194 apiece. Keep in mind that these are temporary, seasonal jobs that end once the road project is complete. Won’t we be in the same situation within a few months’ time? Could we not have turned that funding for one seasonal employee into three permanent jobs? Permanent jobs mean consumer spending, building the tax base and pulling people out of the unemployment lines.
While roads projects are always needed to replace aging infrastructure in the state, could the stimulus money have been spent in a better way? Could boosting unemployment compensation or extending it even longer have been more effective?
Or perhaps subsidizing employment in vital industries, like the manufacturing, steel and aluminum plants in West Virginia. What if some of those funds could have been used for programs that would pay partial salaries of employees as an incentive to hire or maintain the current workforce?
This round of stimulus funds to the states has not been a jobs plan at all. But in all fairness, the states have to play by the rules of the feds.
Perhaps the next round of Obama stimulus funding will focus on true jobs creation. That’s what this economy needs — jobs, jobs and more jobs.
Opinion
Creation of jobs should be focus
- Opinion
-
-
Superintendent, BOE must find accord if schools are to progress
We’re a little confused.
In October, an item appeared on the agenda of a Marion County Board of Education meeting to hire an administrative assistant of Human Resources and Student Support Services. But the item was pulled from the agenda with no public discussion about why, and the position was not filled. -
George Esper: Outstanding man as correspondent and WVU professor
Many West Virginians would no doubt be shocked to learn that the outstanding correspondent from the Vietnam War was a West Virginia University graduate from Uniontown, Pa.
His name was George Esper, one familiar for many years around the WVU School of Journalism for his tenacious coverage of the Vietnam War that established him as a highly revered print reporter of the 20th century. -
Hiding state records has no place in a democracy
In private business and personal life, people may hide some activities, exercising their right of privacy. But government is different.
-
Results about Twitter, free from censorship
So Twitter announces that it will allow country-specific censorship. What followed was #outrage, #disbelief, #protest, #RighteousIndignation, #TwitterBlackout and #rage.
-
West Virginia must develop plan to fulfill highway needs
There is no dispute that improving West Virginia’s roads is one of the state’s biggest needs.
We use them daily — out of necessity and for pleasure.
They’re also vital to West Virginia’s economic health. -
Best interests would be served if FGH and city both move on
In December, Marion County Circuit Court Judge David Janes ruled that the Fairmont General Hospital Board of Directors can appoint its own members and that the City of Fairmont’s charter no longer applies to the hospital.
-
Educational partnership a step in the right direction
Officials involved in a new educational partnership between Pierpont Community & Technical College and FirstEnergy Corp. call the endeavor a “great opportunity.”
We think it’s even more than that. -
Meth causes senseless waste, terrible damage in West Virginia
Terrible damage is inflicted on West Virginia — and upon abusers and their families — because dopeheads feel compelled to blank out their minds with drugs of many sorts. We can’t understand the sad need that impels them. It causes a senseless loss to society and individuals, filling prisons and wrecking jobs.
-
Limited funds for workforce training can’t be wasted through drug abuse
There’s only so much money to go around when it comes to workforce training. And with the national economy still in a bit of a slump, there’s even less money to go around and even more of a reason to make the money invested in these programs count.
-
A better way to choose presidential candidates?
Forty-seven more primaries to go.
If you feel like it’s been a wild Republican primary election season, with accusations of sexual misconduct, candidates coming and going, who makes how much and more, just remember one thing. There are 47 more primaries to go. - More Opinion Headlines
-
Superintendent, BOE must find accord if schools are to progress
