Dissenters have called it the “Fat Tax” — a proposed discount program the state Public Employees Insurance Agency is considering.
The program, if approved by the PEIA, would ask its more than 200,000 state workers, retirees and family members to submit certain health information to determine whether they would be eligible for a discount on premiums. The insured would be asked to provide information on their blood pressure, blood glucose and cholesterol levels and — the source of the nickname — waist circumference.
If insured people hit all the “magic” numbers — or if they can provide a note from their doctor explaining they are working on a healthier lifestyle — they could be eligible for reduced rates. The amount of savings has yet to be determined — the PEIA board will host a public hearing next month before making a decision on the discount program.
We could see both sides of this argument. While the PEIA certainly wants to encourage a healthy lifestyle among the people it insures, we’re just not sure that this is the appropriate way to handle it.
In fact, it seems a little like grasping at straws to balance a budget as health costs soar.
“Fat Tax” is a catchy name that those who do not support the measure have coined. While we wouldn’t go that far, we can also see those with high risk factors would see this as financial punishment for failing to be as genetically balanced as the guy in the next cubicle.
PEIA administrators have compared this program to the $25 charge that smokers have to pay on top of regular PEIA premiums. But we would argue that smoking is a conscious choice. You decide you are going to light a cigarette. And while that decision may eventually trigger a chemical addiction to nicotine, the initial responsibility belongs to you.
But consider the risk factors that PEIA wants to reward some of its customers — high blood pressure, high cholesterol, diabetes, obesity. Doesn’t genetics play strongly into each one of these risk factors? Why don’t we just start taking swabs from newborn babies and determine the health issue they are most likely to suffer from and charge them extra for it?
Here’s a thought. Why don’t we start charging higher premiums to people who frequent tanning beds or refuse to use sunblock? How about those with poor driving records, a habit of not wearing their seat belts or who have had more than one accident? How about customers who consume more than three alcoholic drinks per day? People who run with scissors?
The point is that almost every person insured under PEIA engages in an activity that could be considered a health risk. Why consider punitive action against those who fit into a certain category?
PEIA already has eight distinct programs in place that focus on healthy lifestyles and helping its insured lose weight, quit smoking or other tobacco problems and exercise more, among other programs.
Gov. Joe Manchin is upset about public reaction to the discount program.
“If you look at our track record, we’ve never proposed penalizing or shaming anyone,” he told The Associated Press on Tuesday. “Since the beginning, we’ve been about improving healthy lifestyles. So why, all of a sudden, are we getting kicked in the teeth?”
Obviously there are two sides to this issue, but common sense tells you that it’s not really politically smart to tell your employees “You’re fat, and I’m gonna charge you for it.”
Opinion
Why consider punitive action in bid to lower health costs?
- Opinion
-
-
Cutting ‘non-fraud’ unemployment overpayments can help stabilize fund
It may sound like small potatoes when you’re dealing with annual unemployment compensation of nearly $340 million, but $6.3 million is still a lot of money. And it represents more than 8,000 “non-fraud overpayments” made by the state, a startling fact released late last month.
-
BrickStreet success shows wisdom of privatizing workers’ compensation in state
BrickStreet Mutual Insurance Co., in its fifth year doing business, is a financial success.
You may recall that BrickStreet began its historic role as West Virginia’s first private workers’ compensation carrier on Jan. 1, 2006. West Virginia’s market, by design, has significantly changed since then, but this summer, Greg Burton, the firm’s president and CEO, said BrickStreet is pleased to be surpassing its goals. -
Should other options be considered in war on drugs?
Soon, State Police helicopters will swoop over West Virginia hilltops, spotting lush marijuana patches. The tall plants, worth millions in the underground dope business, will be chopped down and burned. Other clusters missed by troopers will be harvested secretly and funneled into the illicit trade.
-
Labor: Our stabilizing and strengthening force for good
The most grandiose idea birthed in the mind of a brilliant professional will forever remain dormant and useless until it reaches the productive hands of labor.
The American labor force has distinguished itself from generation to generation for its ability to produce, with accuracy and dependability, any task it was given. -
‘The Cure’ for economy remains elusive
When you’ve got a nasty cold, it seems like everyone has The Cure and you’ve just got to try it.
A hot toddy.
Chicken soup and cough syrup.
Orange juice and plenty of rest.
And maybe you’ve tried them a time or two. And, in some cases, The Cure eases the symptoms, but it never makes the cold go away. -
Supercomputer ‘beacon’ builds credibility of I-79 High Tech Corridor
We don’t just consider the announcement of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration’s latest project as one more piece of the I-79 Technology Park puzzle.
When the West Virginia High Tech Consortium announced this week that NOAA would be building a supercomputer in Fairmont at the high-tech park, a lot of words came to mind, but one in particular.
Beacon. -
Love of helping students propels FSHS principal to state recognition
Chad Norman, principal of Fairmont Senior High School, believes that one of the most important aspects of being in his position is loving the students under his guidance.
He says “you have to love to work with kids. And I do love working with them, spending time with them, helping to mold and shape them.” -
New nuisance ordinance will give residents peace and quiet
We’ve all been there.
The neighbors are playing their music at a high volume. So high, in fact, that you can hear the lyrics as plainly as if the music were playing in your own home. It’s getting late, and you’ve got a long day ahead. The police are called, but they can do nothing because of ineffective laws that prohibit citations from being issued. -
Ethics law’s ‘revolving door’ should be reviewed
West Virginia’s governmental ethics law — like its counterpart in nearly every state — bans the “revolving door” custom through which state officials deal with private firms, then resign to take lucrative jobs with the same firms, or quit to become lobbyists pressuring their former colleagues. Somehow, this practice seems too cozy to be desirable.
-
It’s time ‘brick wall’ Greater Marion PSD customers have hit finally is taken down
It’s a situation no one should have to deal with for a day.
Let alone a decade.
Carolina, Idamay and Kellytown residents are still waiting for groundbreaking on a project to grant them relief from numerous sewage system issues that have been plaguing the small communities for years. - More Opinion Headlines
-
Cutting ‘non-fraud’ unemployment overpayments can help stabilize fund
