On the surface the purpose is noble, aiming to reduce use of illegal drugs in West Virginia.
However, we have major problems with a potential bill aiming to implement random drug testing for welfare recipients and state lawmakers that Delegate Craig Blair, R-Berkeley, hopes to introduce in the West Virginia Legislature.
Blair introduced a drug-testing bill during the 2009 legislative session, a measure aimed at testing individuals who received social service payments including welfare, food stamps or jobless benefits. It died without getting out of committee.
Now he has a new bill that will require “random drug testing for recipients of Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) cash benefits and for legislators of the State of West Virginia.”
Those are obviously significant changes from a year ago when there were many more targets for comprehensive, not random, drug testing.
We’ll take Blair at his word when he says his purpose is to help, not punish.
“Under this proposal, if you apply for assistance and test positive for illegal drugs, you have two months to get clean and still receive benefits,” he told the Martinsburg Journal last month. “But this is also new because if two months later, you are in treatment and still test positive for drugs, you still get your payment. We’re trying to help people, give children their parents back, while we also stop substance abuse.”
The legislation, though, has significant problems.
At the top of the list is a constitutional one.
Michigan passed a law in 1999 requiring drug testing for those receiving public assistance, but it was struck down by the 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in 2003. The court ruled that drug testing welfare recipients violated the Fourth Amendment’s protection against unreasonable search and seizure.
The contention that acceptance of state service should lead to ability to randomly test is weak. Would anyone about to drive onto a state road, for example, be subject to a drug test despite showing no suspicious behavior?
Also, randomly testing the relatively small percentage of the population receiving TANF payments would have a miniscule effect on drug use in West Virginia.
There is also the issue of cost. Delegate Sally Susman, D-Raleigh, distributed a press release last month saying the proposal would affect 169,000 people and cost the state $9.7 million. Blair, though, said costs would be much lower because the bill only requires testing for people who are not yet in the state assistance program.
Drug testing is also not foolproof. There are false positives, and there is an underground industry centered on beating the tests.
We strongly support efforts — from education to strong law enforcement — to fight the use of illegal drugs.
Singling out a group of West Virginians for random drug testing is simply not an effective part of that strategy.
Delegate Tim Manchin, D-Marion, made the point well:
“The concept is great, but the complexity is overwhelming. Anybody that tries to reduce the whole thing to something simple is bordering on political grandstanding.”
Opinion
Drug-testing proposal is far from a solution to complex issue
- Opinion
-
-
Quit playing games; ‘do what is right’ in renewing extension of the payroll tax cut
Once again, lawmakers in Washington, D.C., are working on a deal to extend a payroll tax cut for 160 million Americans beyond the end of the month.
And once again, debate has ensued. -
Superintendent, BOE must find accord if schools are to progress
We’re a little confused.
In October, an item appeared on the agenda of a Marion County Board of Education meeting to hire an administrative assistant of Human Resources and Student Support Services. But the item was pulled from the agenda with no public discussion about why, and the position was not filled. -
George Esper: Outstanding man as correspondent and WVU professor
Many West Virginians would no doubt be shocked to learn that the outstanding correspondent from the Vietnam War was a West Virginia University graduate from Uniontown, Pa.
His name was George Esper, one familiar for many years around the WVU School of Journalism for his tenacious coverage of the Vietnam War that established him as a highly revered print reporter of the 20th century. -
Hiding state records has no place in a democracy
In private business and personal life, people may hide some activities, exercising their right of privacy. But government is different.
-
Results about Twitter, free from censorship
So Twitter announces that it will allow country-specific censorship. What followed was #outrage, #disbelief, #protest, #RighteousIndignation, #TwitterBlackout and #rage.
-
West Virginia must develop plan to fulfill highway needs
There is no dispute that improving West Virginia’s roads is one of the state’s biggest needs.
We use them daily — out of necessity and for pleasure.
They’re also vital to West Virginia’s economic health. -
Best interests would be served if FGH and city both move on
In December, Marion County Circuit Court Judge David Janes ruled that the Fairmont General Hospital Board of Directors can appoint its own members and that the City of Fairmont’s charter no longer applies to the hospital.
-
Educational partnership a step in the right direction
Officials involved in a new educational partnership between Pierpont Community & Technical College and FirstEnergy Corp. call the endeavor a “great opportunity.”
We think it’s even more than that. -
Meth causes senseless waste, terrible damage in West Virginia
Terrible damage is inflicted on West Virginia — and upon abusers and their families — because dopeheads feel compelled to blank out their minds with drugs of many sorts. We can’t understand the sad need that impels them. It causes a senseless loss to society and individuals, filling prisons and wrecking jobs.
-
Limited funds for workforce training can’t be wasted through drug abuse
There’s only so much money to go around when it comes to workforce training. And with the national economy still in a bit of a slump, there’s even less money to go around and even more of a reason to make the money invested in these programs count.
- More Opinion Headlines
-
Quit playing games; ‘do what is right’ in renewing extension of the payroll tax cut
